🌎 Now shipping across Asia & Oceania See rates & delivery →
Cardian

Cardian Research · Short read

Vintage Pokémon's record run hits its first real test

At one auction on 25 October, 37 of 39 Legendary Collection PSA 10s sold for less than their previous sale, with a median fall of 41%. Our vintage index is still up almost six times since early 2024.

28 Oct 2026 · 2 min read

For most of this year, vintage Pokémon has been setting records almost every week. Prices for some cards doubled in a matter of weeks, and two weeks ago we asked who was pushing them up. On Sunday 25 October the market gave its first clear answer, and it was not a good one for anyone who bought at the top.

That night Fanatics sold 317 Legendary Collection reverse holos in a single auction. We matched 39 of the PSA 10s to the last time each card sold, and 37 of them went for less. The 39 cards had last sold for a combined US$1.69 million. This time they fetched US$1.01 million, a median drop of 41%.

One card shows the whole story. A PSA 10 Dark Dragonite sold for about US$60K in June and US$384K on 19 October, six times more in four months. Six days later it went for US$192K. It was not just one auction house either: a PSA 10 Pikachu from the same set sold for US$780K on 28 September and US$481.9K on 26 October.

Were the highs real? They were paid for, but each record was one card, one buyer, one evening. PSA has graded only 44 Dark Dragonites as a 10, so a couple of keen bidders can set the price for all of them. Meanwhile supply woke up. Fanatics' weekly auctions went from 60 of these cards on 4 October to 317 on 25 October. When prices rise six times, the binders come out, and last Sunday the buyers did not keep up.

Our own data puts this in proportion. Cardian's vintage index of English PSA 10s from 1999 to 2007 is still up almost six times since early 2024, and it has not cracked. The selling started in the hottest corner of the market, which is usually how it goes: stretched first, cracked later.

We have seen this before. In 2023 Japan's 'waifu' cards, the trainer cards featuring popular female characters, fell more than 90% from their peak, and most of them never came back. Not everything is a bubble. A first-edition Charizard dipped after 2021 and has since sold for US$1.38 million. But in this hobby a price only means something if someone pays it and someone else would too. Don't chase the hype; buy what you actually love.

Auction results: Fanatics Collect sales history, pulled 26 Oct 2026; public sale records as dated. Vintage index: Cardian, English PSA 10s 1999 to 2007, monthly, Jan 2023 to Oct 2026.

See on Instagram

All research →