Cardian Research · Market · Grading · Japanese cards
Slabs turned first. Now raw has to follow
Japanese Pokémon lost about 40% between April and October, then graded cards jumped 23% in under two weeks. Here's what happened, what the bounce looks like in detail, and the one sign that tells you whether it will last.
In April, Japanese Pokémon cards were at record prices. The easiest trade in the hobby was to buy a new card, send it to PSA for grading and sell the 10 for well over what you paid. By 1 October those same PSA 10s were down 37% from their peak. Then, in under two weeks, they jumped 23%, while the ungraded copies of the same cards barely moved.
If you collect, that gap is the part to watch. This piece explains how we got here, what the bounce looks like in detail, and why I think raw prices over the next few weeks matter more than anything happening to slabs. All the charts use the Cardian Pokémon (JP) index, which tracks the 100 most-traded Japanese cards from real sales in Japan. We calculate it twice: once for raw cards (ungraded, straight from the pack) and once for PSA 10s (graded a perfect 10 and sealed in a plastic case, the "slab").
What happened
A hot spring, an overloaded grading queue, and a bounce that failed
From the first week of January to late April, raw Japanese cards rose 68% and PSA 10s rose 45%. A lot of that was flipping, meaning buying to resell quickly. People bought the newest cards to grade them rather than to keep them, because the price gap between a raw card and its PSA 10 made grading look like free money. That works until too many people do it at once. By May the queue at PSA was so long that the company stopped accepting orders for its cheapest services, first in Japan on 15 May and then in the US in early June.
Japanese Pokémon, rebased so 5 Jan 2026 = 100, daily. End labels: change from each April top
Raw ran harder on the way up and fell harder on the way down. The summer bounce in PSA 10s is the one to remember.
Source: Cardian Pokémon (JP) indices: the 100 most-traded Japanese cards, from sold prices in Japan, raw and PSA 10 (cardian.sg/market/method)
Once grading stalled, the flippers had no reason to buy raw cards, and raw prices kept sliding through the summer. PSA 10s did something more misleading. With almost no new slabs coming out of PSA, the ones already on the market became scarce, and from 30 June to mid-August the PSA 10 index climbed 22% while raw fell. It looked like a recovery, and plenty of people called it one. It wasn't, because nobody was buying the raw cards.
In August and September, PSA started returning its backlog of cards. The extra supply arrived just as everyone was getting ready for the big 30th anniversary release in mid-September, and PSA 10s dropped 35% in seven weeks.
By the end, raw and graded cards had both lost roughly 40% from their April peaks. That matters, because it means this was never only a "slab crash". Raw fell slightly more than graded. The whole market had run too hot. The PSA problems decided when and how it fell, not how far.
What's happening now
1 October: the turn
Our PSA 10 index bottomed on 1 October. By 13 October it was 23% higher, which is a very large move for a group of 100 cards in under two weeks. Raw bottomed a few days later and is roughly where it was on 1 October.
Rebased so 1 Aug 2026 = 100, daily
From 1 to 13 October the PSA 10 index rose 23%. Raw moved +0.3%.
Source: Cardian Pokémon (JP) indices: the 100 most-traded Japanese cards, from sold prices in Japan, raw and PSA 10 (cardian.sg/market/method)
A jump like that can come from just a few expensive cards, so the first thing I checked was breadth, meaning how many cards in the index are actually rising. In mid-September breadth was about as bad as it gets: on 18 September, of the 94 PSA 10s that moved more than 1% that week, 92 were down. This week 89 of 93 are up, so this is the whole market moving, not a few lucky cards.
PSA 10s in the index rising vs falling over the past 7 days (by more than 1%), each day
On 18 September only 2 PSA 10s in the index were up on the week. This isn't a few lucky cards.
Source: Cardian Pokémon (JP) indices: the 100 most-traded Japanese cards, from sold prices in Japan, raw and PSA 10 (cardian.sg/market/method)
It's also not limited to one part of the market. When I split the index by era, PSA 10s from Sword & Shield and older are up about 25% since 1 October, Scarlet & Violet about 23%, and even the newest Mega cards about 15%. The raw copies of those same cards are flat or slightly down in every group.
Median price change since 1 Oct, cards in the index
The newest Mega cards rose the least, but even they were up about 15%. The older eras led.
Source: Cardian Pokémon (JP) indices: the 100 most-traded Japanese cards, from sold prices in Japan, raw and PSA 10 (cardian.sg/market/method)
What's next
We've seen this before, and it went both ways
The obvious question is whether raw follows. To find out, I went through every rebound in our Japanese and One Piece indices since 2024. For each one I asked the same question: once PSA 10s had climbed 10% from their low, how long did raw take to do the same?
Days between PSA 10s and raw cards each climbing 10% off their lows
When raw followed, it took about two weeks (2 to 32 days). Twice it didn't: early 2025, when raw led, and this July.
Source: Cardian Pokémon (JP) and One Piece (JP) indices, raw and PSA 10. A recovery = 10% above the low; raw low taken within 45 days of the PSA 10 low
Five times out of seven, graded went first and raw followed, usually within about two weeks (anywhere from 2 to 32 days). That fits how the hobby works. The people trading slabs tend to be quicker and follow the market more closely, so they move first. Collectors buying raw cards are more careful and wait to be sure. Once they're convinced, this bigger, slower part of the market catches up.
The two exceptions teach us the most. In early 2025 raw turned first, so slabs don't always lead. And this July, slabs rose and raw never followed. That's the bounce that collapsed. Putting the cases side by side makes the difference clear.
Japanese Pokémon, the 100 days after each PSA 10 low (low = 100)
In October 2024 raw caught up within weeks and both ran. In July 2026 it never did, and the slab rally collapsed.
Source: Cardian Pokémon (JP) indices: the 100 most-traded Japanese cards, from sold prices in Japan, raw and PSA 10 (cardian.sg/market/method)
In October 2024, raw caught up within weeks and both indices rose about 60% over the next hundred days. In June 2024 and July 2026, PSA 10s jumped on their own and then lost it all again. We're now 12 days into the current bounce, which is still too early to tell which kind it is.
What's next
Why raw is waiting, and what could get it moving
I can see two reasons raw is slow this time. The first is simply that raw buyers are cautious after a 40% fall, and that's normal. The second is specific to 2026: a lot of raw demand in the spring came from people buying cards to grade, and PSA's cheap tiers are still shut. Until they reopen, those buyers are missing.
PSA has said it will reopen the cheap tiers once the queue is under 5 million cards. The queue was about 12.4 million in late July and 9 million by 22 September. If it keeps falling at the pace it did through September, it reaches 5 million around 20 November. That's my own estimate, not a PSA date, but it puts a likely trigger for raw prices about five weeks away.
Cards waiting at PSA, millions
The projection is mine, a straight line at the late-August to September pace. PSA hasn't given a date.
Source: The Card Shop Finder PSA backlog figures (late Jul to 22 Sep 2026); Sports Illustrated Collectibles (1 Jul 2026); Cardian projection
The last thing I'm watching is the premium, which is how many times the raw price a PSA 10 sells for. It peaked at 3.62 times in June, when slabs were scarce, and fell to 2.50 times in late September as the backlog came back graded. It's now 2.92 times. For Japanese cards, somewhere around 2.5 to 3 times raw has been normal, so slabs aren't expensive yet. If the premium rises well past 3.2 times again while raw stays flat, that would look a lot like July.
Median PSA 10 price ÷ raw price, same card, Japanese Pokémon, weekly
Around 2.5 to 3 times raw has been normal for Japanese cards. Above about 3.2, grading your own raw copy starts to look better than buying the slab.
Source: Cardian PSA 10 premium, Japanese Pokémon: median across cards with both a raw and a PSA 10 price (cardian.sg/market/premium)
On 25 September I wrote "Older PSA 10s: now, slowly. New Mega cards: after late November", and I'm still buying older PSA 10s a little at a time. I'm not buying faster just because PSA 10s are up 23%. I'd rather see raw confirm first, and I'll update these charts as the numbers come in.