Cardian Research · Vintage · Grading · Valuation · Market
Who sets the price of an $8.4 million Pikachu?
A Raincoat Pikachu sold for $8.4 million in September. Two weeks later another copy, same grade, went for $1.04 million. Here's why vintage prices jump like that, who is bringing the new money, and how I'd check a vintage price before paying it.
On 27 September a PSA 10 Raincoat Pikachu sold at Fanatics Collect for $8.4 million, about 54 times the $156,250 the same card in the same grade sold for at Heritage in June. On 11 October another PSA 10 copy sold at Goldin for $1.04 million. Both auctions drew 64 bids, two weeks apart, and one price was eight times the other.
So which number is the card worth? This piece looks at why vintage prices move like that, who has been paying them, the part people would rather not talk about, and the checks I'd do before paying.
What happened
Two copies, two weeks, one price eight times the other
The Raincoat Pikachu is a 2015 Japanese promo, printed for winners of a drawing contest tied to the 3DS game Pokémon Art Academy and never sold in shops. PSA has graded 57 copies a perfect 10. The September winning bid was $7 million, and the auction house's fee (the buyer's premium) took it to $8.4 million. Kotaku called the price "inexplicable". At Goldin two weeks later the winning bid was $850,000, or $1.04 million with the 22% premium.
Raincoat Pikachu (2015 Art Academy promo), PSA 10, public auction results incl. buyer's premium
Both September and October auctions drew 64 bids. The October price was about an eighth of September's.
Source: Kotaku (30 Sep 2026) for Heritage and Fanatics Collect; Polkastarter sale log (12 Oct 2026) for Goldin
It wasn't one strange night. Between late August and late September several rare cards set records far above their last sales. A Torchic Gold Star PSA 10 from 2004's Team Rocket Returns sold for $2.7 million at Alt, where its last public sale had been $25,400 in December 2020. A 2015 Art Academy Mudkip, one of only three PSA 10s, sold for $3.72 million in Fanatics' September Premier Auction.
Why prices jump
A few dozen perfect copies, and even fewer buyers
What these cards share is how few perfect copies exist. PSA lists 19 Torchic Gold Stars in a 10. To see whether that's normal, I took the 25 most valuable English PSA 10s from each era and counted their 10s across PSA and CGC.
Median number of 10s (PSA and CGC) among each era's 25 most valuable English PSA 10s
Up to XY, a top card typically has a few dozen perfect copies. From Sword & Shield on, a few thousand.
Source: Cardian population data from PSA and CGC population reports, 12 Oct 2026; the 25 cards are ranked by our PSA 10 prices, median of those whose count is known (cardian.sg/market)
For the old eras it is normal. The typical top WOTC (Wizards of the Coast) card has 69 perfect copies and the typical top EX card about 56, while the top Scarlet & Violet cards have 2,574 each. That's also why "vintage" here is more about scarcity than age: the Raincoat Pikachu is only eleven years old, but with 57 copies it trades like a 2004 Gold Star rather than a modern chase card.
There are also few buyers. In our English data the typical WOTC card had 85 recorded sales in the past year, compared with 414 for a typical Scarlet & Violet card.
When a card with a few dozen perfect copies comes up only a few times a year, its price is whatever the two keenest bidders that night will pay. If one of them has unusual amounts of money or an unusual reason to want it, the price multiplies, and the next auction, with a different crowd, can bring it straight back down. A modern card with thousands of 10s and daily sales doesn't work that way, because no single buyer can hold the price up for long.
Who's buying
The new money is real, but it's concentrated
None of this means the money is fake. Our English PSA 10 index follows the 100 most-traded English PSA 10s by value, and 98 of them date from 2016 or earlier, so it's basically a vintage index. It's up 82% this year, while the raw (ungraded) index is up 28%.
Cardian Pokémon (EN) indices, rebased so 1 Jan 2026 = 100, monthly to 12 Oct
Most of the PSA 10 gain came from January to June (+67%). From 1 August, through every record auction, the basket moved +0.4%.
Source: Cardian Pokémon (EN) indices: the 100 most-traded English cards by traded value, from sold prices, raw and PSA 10. 98 of the 100 PSA 10s date from 2016 or earlier (cardian.sg/market/method)
The timing matters, though. Most of that gain came between January and June, and from 1 August, all through the record auctions, the index moved less than half a percent. Our 8 October carousel quoted an outside index: "Graded Pokémon cards: +78% in the last 3 months (Card Ladder)". From 1 July to 12 October, our English PSA 10 index rose 9%. The records were a few cards being bid up hard, not the whole top of the market rising.
The most visible new buyer is the crypto pack site. You buy a digital "gacha" pack on your phone, each pull is backed by a real graded card in a vault, and you can keep it, trade it or sell it back. To fill those packs the platforms must buy real cards, and the expensive packs are sold on the promise of a grail (a top dream card).
Money spent per month on crypto 'gacha' packs backed by real graded cards, US$ millions
July was the first monthly fall since February, down 18%, and still the second-biggest month on record.
Source: Blockworks Research, 'Gacha Cools Off' (7 Aug 2026); June 2025 figure from Blockworks Research via Cointelegraph (16 Jul 2026)
According to Blockworks Research, spending on these packs reached $354.8 million in June, about seven times the roughly $50 million of a year earlier. The biggest platform, Collector Crypt, took $209.5 million of that, and its $2,500 packs alone had brought in $82.9 million by the end of June. July was the first monthly fall since February, but it was still the second-biggest month on record.
Japan's oripa (mystery-pack) operators buy for the same reason: in June Nihon Toreca Center, one of the country's largest, ran a collaboration built around PSA 10 vintage starters and Pikachu promos. Then there are a few very wealthy collectors, like whoever paid $16.5 million for the PSA 10 Pikachu Illustrator at Goldin in February.
Funds move the slowest, but they tell us the most. In March, Hong Kong-listed MemeStrategy launched a tokenised fund for professional investors that aims to own about 25% of all PSA 10 Pikachu with Grey Felt Hat cards, the 2023 Van Gogh Museum promo. Our data counts 48,441 graded 10s of that card, so the fund chose a card with a deep market, where one bid can't move the price.
The part nobody likes
Thin markets are easy to push, and grades aren't always right
The same lack of buyers and sellers that lets real money move a price also makes it easy to fake one. The tactics are well known. A seller can sell a card to a friend at a high price, then list it again with that "sale" as proof. Or a winning bidder may never pay, leaving a record price that was never actually paid. A third is shill bidding, meaning bidding up your own lot through friends or other accounts.
There's a public record of the last one. In August 2021, Axios reported that eBay had restricted PWCC, then one of the biggest card sellers, and removed more than 71,000 of its listings over shill-bidding claims, which PWCC denied. In April 2025 Alt sued PWCC, which Fanatics bought in 2023 and which now runs Fanatics Collect. Alt alleged that from 2021 to 2023 a group "fraudulently and collusively bid up items". PWCC called the suit "completely baseless".
Those were sports-card auctions, and I have no evidence of anything wrong in this year's Pokémon sales. My point is a smaller one. When one auction sets the price of a card with 19 copies, very little stops that number from being wrong.
Even the slab isn't a guarantee. In 2025 collectors alleged that CGC-graded "1990s prototype" Pokémon cards, which together sold for over $1 million, had been printed in 2024, and CGC said it was investigating. Grades also aren't always consistent, and on vintage cards that gets expensive, because so few old cards earn a 10.
Share of graded copies that got a 10 (PSA and CGC), median of each era's 25 most valuable English PSA 10s
On a 25-year-old card, a 10 is the rare exception. That makes the call between a 9 and a 10 worth a great deal.
Source: Cardian population data from PSA and CGC population reports, 12 Oct 2026 (cardian.sg/market)
Only about 3 in 100 graded copies of a top WOTC card made a 10, compared with 30 in 100 for Scarlet & Violet. So a 10 on an old card is the rare exception, and the gap between a 9 and a 10 is where most of the value sits.
PSA 10 price ÷ PSA 9 price of the same card, median per era
Across eras and both languages the last grade point is worth 2.3 to 7.2 times. It's highest on English EX and XY cards.
Source: Cardian graded-price ladder: cards with both a PSA 9 and a PSA 10 price, raw worth US$10 or more, 13 Oct 2026 (cardian.sg/market)
On a WOTC card, a PSA 10 sells for about five times a PSA 9. That's why a case reported by Cardlines in April hurt so much. A submitter's 30 cards, including 2019 Pokémon Tag Team cards, all came back PSA 9 and were sold to PSA's buyback programme at $35 each, and weeks later 11 of them reappeared as PSA 10s. PSA called it a "one-off grading error", while Nat Turner, who heads PSA's parent company, acknowledged a "systematic failure".
Before you pay
How I'd check a vintage price
I enjoy watching these auctions as much as anyone, but I wouldn't use them to price a collection, and I'd only buy at that level with money I could leave alone for years.