Cardian Research · Market · Japanese cards · One Piece · Valuation · Buyer's guide
Real demand vs expected demand: why One Piece slabs fell further
Our 30 July carousel carried the line "Why Pokémon bent — and One Piece broke." By 1 October One Piece slabs were 51% below their June peak and Pokémon slabs 37% below April's, Our data shows the fall hit the speculative money wherever it was, and there are signs you can spot before you buy.
On 10 June, every one of the 98 One Piece PSA 10s in our index that moved that week went up. Ten days later, 83 of 91 were going down, and by 1 October the index was 51% below its peak. Japanese Pokémon slabs fell as well, 37% from their April top, but they had climbed more slowly and they gave back less.
On 30 July we posted a carousel with one idea to explain the difference: real demand versus expected demand. This piece tests that idea on our data up to 13 October, compares what we wrote with what happened next, and ends with how to tell which kind of demand is behind a card before you buy. The charts use the Cardian Pokémon (JP) and One Piece (JP) indices, which track the 100 most-traded Japanese cards of each game from sold prices in Japan, both raw (ungraded) and PSA 10.
The idea
Every price is two kinds of demand stacked on top of each other
Real demand is buying a card for the card itself: a player who needs it in a deck, a collector filling a binder, someone who wants the slab on a shelf. That buyer doesn't need anyone to pay more later, so they're still around when prices fall. That's why real demand sets the floor, the level prices tend to stop at.
Expected demand is buying for the next price. It's the flipper, the person who buys raw to grade and sell, and the money that turns up because a chart went up. Each of those buyers needs a later buyer, so expected demand sets the ceiling, and it leaves as soon as the price stops rising.
Nobody labels their purchase, so neither kind can be measured directly. What we can measure are the signs it leaves, and these are clues, not counts. Expected demand tends to arrive fast and all at once, so I look at how much of a climb came in its last eight weeks and how many cards rose in the same week. It goes for whatever is easiest to resell, which in this hobby is the slab, so I watch the PSA 10 premium, meaning how many times the raw price a PSA 10 sells for. Real demand only shows up afterwards, in where a fall stops.
What happened
One climbed, one jumped
From 1 January 2025 to its 18 April peak, the Pokémon PSA 10 index rose 2.8 times, with 37% of the gain arriving in the final eight weeks. One Piece slabs moved sideways for most of 2025 and then rose 4.4 times between 1 December and an 11 June peak. Measured from January 2025 they rose 4.7 times, and 71% of that came in the last eight weeks.
PSA 10 indices, Japanese cards, rebased so 1 Jan 2025 = 100, daily. End labels: now vs each peak
71% of One Piece's climb since January 2025 came in the eight weeks before its peak. For Pokémon it was 37%.
Source: Cardian Pokémon (JP) and One Piece (JP) indices: the 100 most-traded Japanese cards of each game, from sold prices in Japan (cardian.sg/market/method)
The revised version of that July carousel put it this way: "A staircase is a lot of people deciding separately. A spike is one crowd deciding at once." Breadth, meaning how many cards in the index are rising versus falling, shows that crowd clearly. In mid-May and again on 10 June, all 98 One Piece slabs that moved more than 1% in a week moved up, and by 20 June the picture had flipped.
One Piece (JP) PSA 10s in the index rising vs falling over the past 7 days (by more than 1%), each day
Every card moving the same way in the same week looks like one crowd deciding at once. It turned in ten days.
Source: Cardian One Piece (JP) PSA 10 index: the 100 most-traded Japanese One Piece PSA 10s, from sold prices in Japan (cardian.sg/market/method)
It's the clearest picture of expected demand an index can give. But cards moving together is an unreliable measure on its own. One Piece raw cards, which held up best, often rose together too, partly because far fewer of them trade.
What we said vs what happened
Pokémon slabs rose 16% in July, then fell 35%
The revised July carousel said of Pokémon that "the index RECOVERED most of the ground in July (+13% month on month), supported by healthy underlying demand". On our index, PSA 10s fell 15% in June and rose 16% in July, while raw Japanese cards fell 0.5% in July. From 14 August to 1 October PSA 10s then fell 35%, for reasons covered in our piece on the sell-off.
For One Piece, the carousel's cover read "-27% since June peak". Our index puts that peak on 11 June, with slabs 25% below it at the end of July. The fall then continued to 51% by 1 October. Of the Pokémon climb, the carousel said "≈+150%, but never more than ~20% in a single move". Our PSA 10 index rose 155% from January 2025 to July 2026, including 27% from 1 December 2025 to 1 January 2026.
What the data says
The fall hit the expected demand wherever it was
Splitting each game into raw and graded adds detail. One Piece slabs fell furthest of the four indices, but One Piece raw fell only 33%, the least, while Pokémon raw fell 42%, more than Pokémon slabs. So the better question is where in each game the speculation was.
Putting all four side by side makes the pattern clear: the more of a climb that came in its final eight weeks, the deeper the fall that followed.
Share of each index's climb (1 Jan 2025 to its 2026 peak) made in the final 8 weeks, and the fall from peak to low
Four cases rank the same way on both measures. That's a pattern, not proof.
Source: Cardian Pokémon (JP) and One Piece (JP) indices: the 100 most-traded Japanese cards of each game, from sold prices in Japan (cardian.sg/market/method)
In One Piece the expected demand was in the slabs. The PSA 10 premium went from 2.5 times raw in early April to 4.9 times in mid-June, and raw cards kept climbing for five weeks after slabs peaked, adding 3.8% by 20 July. Players need raw cards to play, and that's the side that held. In Pokémon it was in raw cards, because spring buyers were grabbing new cards to grade and sell, so raw ran harder on the way up and fell harder on the way down.
Median PSA 10 price ÷ raw price, same card, Japanese cards, weekly
A slab is the easiest version of a card to resell. When buyers pay double the usual multiple for it, they are paying for the exit.
Source: Cardian PSA 10 premium: median across cards with both a raw and a PSA 10 price, Japanese Pokémon and One Piece (cardian.sg/market/premium)
More One Piece slabs traded in June, so the number of cards behind that peak grew from 121 to 320. Treat the exact figure as rough. The premium is now back to 2.65 times, close to where it sat before the rush.
Where the falls stopped is our clearest clue to real demand, and it tells the same story in both games. The Pokémon PSA 10 low on 1 October matched the index's level of 25 December 2025, so the fall wiped out the spring rise and nothing older. One Piece slabs bottomed at their level of 6 May, where the final spike began, and they're still 2.6 times their January 2025 level. In both cases the fast rise disappeared, and the slow climb underneath it stayed.
Set by set
In One Piece, the sets that ran furthest fell furthest
The 30 July carousel also contrasted One Piece's old and new sets, saying of OP-01 to OP-08 "Never reprinted into oblivion" and of the newest sets "Print runs ran past organic demand". Our set curves follow the most-traded raw cards in each set from launch week, For the eight sets released since late 2024, how far a set had risen is a better guide to its fall than its age.
One Piece (JP) sets released since late 2024 (OP = booster, EB = extra, PRB = premium): top raw cards, now vs their 2026 peak. Under each code: peak vs launch week
Not every newest set fell hardest. The ones that had run furthest above launch did.
Source: Cardian One Piece (JP) set curves: the 15 most-traded raw cards of each set (fewer for small sets), from sold prices in Japan; launch week = 100
Anime 25th Collection (EB02) is the extreme case. Its basket peaked at 14 times its launch-week level, and its Monkey.D.Luffy leader parallel still trades at about 21 times its launch-week price, yet the set is 54% below its peak. Royal Blood (OP10) only ever rose 25% and has given back 18%. The two newest sets fell about 41–42% after big rises, and a June report from Misprint listed OP-13 and EB-03 among 2026's reprints. Our curves stop two years after release, so OP-01 to OP-09 can't be tested this way.
What's next
How to tell which demand you're buying
None of this needs our data. Before buying a card or a set, these are the five checks I'd run:
- Where did the rise happen? If most of the gain came in the last eight weeks, assume a large part of the price is expectation.
- Is everything moving together? When nearly every card in a set rises in the same week, it's usually one crowd moving, not many collectors deciding separately.
- Is the slab running away from the raw card? Japanese Pokémon PSA 10s sold for a median 2.2 times raw in 2025 and 2.7 times in early 2026, and One Piece for about 2.6 times in early 2026. Well above that, buyers are paying for the chance to sell on.
- Where was it before the rush? The price before the last fast leg is a realistic floor. Both games fell back to about there this year.
- Would you still want it if you could never sell it? That price is your real demand. Everything above it is someone else's expectation.
On 30 July we wrote: "We don't chase hype. We don't fear drops." We still buy that way. My own view, from these charts rather than a forecast, is that the floors in both games look real and the next leg up should be judged by whether raw joins it. I'll update these numbers as they come in.