🌎 Now shipping across Asia & Oceania See rates & delivery →
Cardian

Cardian Research · Valuation · Grading · Buyer's guide · Japanese cards

What makes a card worth holding? We tested our own 5,000 rule

Scarcity explains a US$16.49 million Pikachu with one PSA 10. It doesn't explain a Mew ex with 26,817 of them that still ranks among Japan's most expensive modern cards. Here's what our population data says really decides value, and what has happened since to the four cards from our March "Project Overpriced" post.

22 Mar 2026 · Updated 13 Oct 2026 · 10 min read

On 16 February a PSA 10 Pikachu Illustrator, the only copy PSA has ever graded a 10, sold at Goldin for US$16.49 million. That one is easy to explain: one perfect copy, the most loved character in the hobby, and a story nobody can reprint. The harder case is the Japanese Mew ex from Shiny Treasure ex, which has 26,817 graded 10s and is still the fourth most valuable Japanese Scarlet & Violet PSA 10 in our data.

So scarcity can't be the whole answer. This piece uses our own population data, meaning how many copies PSA and CGC have graded a 10. I matched it to PSA 10 sold prices for about 2,500 English and Japanese cards to work out what really decides a card's value. Along the way I test a rule we set in February against that data, follow four cards from a March post, and finish with a checklist you can use on any card before buying it to hold.

What decides it

Four things, and scarcity is only one of them

On 22 March we wrote on Instagram: "Not every rare card goes up in price. These 4 factors decide if a card will hold (or grow) its value over time." The four were IP popularity, aesthetic consensus, story and context, and scarcity and population.

In plainer words, the first is the character: Charizard, Pikachu, Umbreon and Gengar have buyers in every generation, so their cards always find a buyer. The second is art that most collectors agree is beautiful. The third is story, like a promo from a film or event, a famous illustrator, or a card from the set people grew up with. The fourth is scarcity, which for graded cards means the population: how many copies exist in the top grade.

The website version on 24 March added the line that matters most here: "the higher a card's population, the more of the other factors it needs to succeed". Above 10,000 PSA 10s, its table said a card "Requires all three — popularity, story AND art". The next two charts show how population and price line up in our data, era by era.

What the data says

A 10 is worth what it costs to get one

The clearest pattern in our data isn't about price at all. It's about the multiple: how many times the raw (ungraded) price a PSA 10 sells for. The multiple lines up almost perfectly with how hard a 10 is to get. The chart below sorts each era by its gem rate, the share of graded copies that come back a 10.

Chart 1Where 1 card in 8 gets a 10, a PSA 10 is worth 30× raw; where 6 in 7 do, 3.5×

Median PSA 10 price ÷ raw price by era. In brackets: the median share of graded copies that got a 10. Black: English; grey: Japanese

0×10×20×30×EXEnglish30× (12%)WOTCEnglish17.1× (18%)Scarlet & VioletEnglish7.1× (34%)Sun & MoonEnglish8.4× (40%)WOTCJapanese15× (46%)Sword & ShieldEnglish5.8× (54%)Sun & MoonJapanese4.6× (57%)XYJapanese7× (62%)MegaEnglish5.3× (67%)MegaJapanese3.4× (84%)Sword & ShieldJapanese3.2× (85%)Scarlet & VioletJapanese3.5× (86%)0×10×20×30×EXEnglish30× (12%)WOTCEnglish17.1× (18%)Scarlet & VioletEnglish7.1× (34%)Sun & MoonEnglish8.4× (40%)WOTCJapanese15× (46%)Sword & ShieldEnglish5.8× (54%)Sun & MoonJapanese4.6× (57%)XYJapanese7× (62%)MegaEnglish5.3× (67%)MegaJapanese3.4× (84%)Sword & ShieldJapanese3.2× (85%)Scarlet & VioletJapanese3.5× (86%)

The fewer 10s an era produces, the more a 10 is worth over the raw card. Modern Japanese cards gem so easily that a 10 adds only about 3.5×.

Source: Cardian grade ladder (cards worth US$10+ raw) and grading data by era, PSA + CGC populations, 13 Oct 2026

Across the twelve era and language groups, the rank correlation between gem rate and the multiple is −0.92. That means the two move almost perfectly in opposite directions: the harder a 10 is to get, the bigger the multiple. English EX-era cards get a 10 about one time in eight, and a PSA 10 sells for 30 times raw. Modern Japanese cards come back a 10 about six times in seven, so a PSA 10 sells for only about 3.5 times raw. That's why a big pop (population) on a modern Japanese card is less worrying than it sounds: the market already prices the slab as common.

Population also affects price, but only clearly in older cards. Within each English era, I measured how much cheaper a card with ten times as many 10s tends to be.

Chart 210× more PSA 10s cut vintage prices 37%; modern prices didn't fall

English Pokémon: how much lower (or higher) the PSA 10 price is for a card with 10× as many 10s, within the same era

−20%0%VintageXY and older−37%Sword & Shield2020–23+10%Scarlet & Violet2023–25+14%Mega2025–26+9%−20%0%VintageXY and older−37%Sword & Shield2020–23+10%Scarlet & Violet2023–25+14%Mega2025–26+9%

Vintage behaves the textbook way. In modern eras the most-graded cards are the ones people want, so a big pop and a high price go together. Cards in each group: 1,093, 152, 678, 100.

Source: Cardian pop-vs-price data: PSA + CGC 10 counts and PSA 10 sold prices, 2,191 English and 349 Japanese cards worth US$100+ as a PSA 10, 13 Oct 2026

For vintage cards, ten times as many 10s means a price about 37% lower, which is what you'd expect. In Sword & Shield, Scarlet & Violet and Mega, the most-graded cards are slightly more expensive. Japanese cards show the same thing: after allowing for era, ten times as many 10s lowers the price by only 17%. In modern sets the cause runs both ways. People send the cards they want to PSA, so a huge pop is often a sign of demand rather than something holding the price down.

Testing the rule

5,000 PSA 10s is a warning, not a ceiling

On 25 February a website post of ours set out what it called the Cardian Rule: "if a card has more than 5,000 copies in PSA 10, it's usually high-risk — or low-upside — as an ‘investment’, on a risk-adjusted basis". Among modern cards worth at least US$100 as a PSA 10, the ones with more than 5,000 tens sell for more than the typical card of their era, not less. Our counts add PSA and CGC tens together, but CGC is a small share for these cards, so the line falls in the same place.

Chart 3Modern cards with over 5,000 PSA 10s sell for more, not less

Modern Pokémon (Sword & Shield to Mega) worth US$100+ as a PSA 10: median PSA 10 price ÷ the median card of its era, by number of 10s

EnglishJapanese
0×0.5×1×1.5×2×0.99×0.97×Under 1,0000.85×0.97×1,000 to 5,0001.46×1.15×Over 5,0000×1×2×0.99×0.97×Under 1,0000.85×0.97×1,000 to 5,0001.46×1.15×Over 5,000

English cards with over 5,000 tens sit at 1.46× their era's median, and 31% of them are worth twice the median or more. A big pop is not a price ceiling.

Source: Cardian pop-vs-price data: PSA + CGC 10 counts and PSA 10 sold prices, 2,191 English and 349 Japanese cards worth US$100+ as a PSA 10, 13 Oct 2026

The famous cards make the same point. Umbreon VMAX from Evolving Skies has 22,550 tens and is still the eighth most valuable English Sword & Shield PSA 10 in our data. Of the 25 most expensive Japanese Scarlet & Violet PSA 10s, we know the pop of 16, and 12 of those have more than 5,000 tens. Sun & Moon is different: none of that era's top cards whose pop we know, English or Japanese, has more than 5,000, which is what you'd expect from that era's smaller print runs and tougher grading.

The February rule was about value "on a risk-adjusted basis", and a snapshot of today's prices can't test risk. A card with 20,000 tens that is still being printed can add another 20,000, and that supply has to find buyers. We don't yet have long enough price histories for single cards matched to their pops to measure returns properly, so I'd treat 5,000 as a signal to check how fast the pop is growing, not a reason to walk away.

What separates a high-pop card that holds its value from one that doesn't is mostly the art and the story. Here are four pairs of the same Pokémon, each with a similar number of tens.

Chart 4Same Pokémon, similar pop: the chase art sells for 5× to 41× more

English PSA 10 price of the chase card ÷ the other card, with PSA + CGC 10s of each in thousands. Umbreon ex #161 v promo #176; Mega Gengar ex #284 v gold #269; Charizard ex 151 #199 v Mega Charizard X promo #23; Pikachu ex #238 v #219

0×20×40×Umbreon ex5.9k v 8.9k41×Mega Gengar ex8.9k v 3.6k13×Charizard29.7k v 28.5k9.8×Pikachu ex11.5k v 10.0k4.9×0×20×40×Umbreon ex5.9k v 8.9k41×Mega Gengar ex8.9k v 3.6k13×Charizard29.7k v 28.5k9.8×Pikachu ex11.5k v 10.0k4.9×

The chase Mega Gengar has 2.5× as many 10s as the gold one and still costs 13× more. Supply sets the floor; art and story set the price.

Source: Cardian pop-vs-price data: PSA + CGC 10 counts and PSA 10 sold prices, 2,191 English and 349 Japanese cards worth US$100+ as a PSA 10, 13 Oct 2026

The Prismatic Evolutions Umbreon ex illustration rare sells for 41 times the promo Umbreon ex, and it has fewer tens. The Scarlet & Violet 151 Charizard ex illustration rare and a Mega Charizard X promo each have about 29,000 tens, yet one sells for almost ten times the other. Grail cards, the small group worth more than any population line predicts, follow their own rules, which we covered in our piece on the $8.4 million Pikachu.

What we said

The four "Project Overpriced" cards fell 20% to 42% since March

On 17 March we posted "Project Overpriced → We Draw Our Own": four modern Japanese special art rares (SARs), each shown with its price, its PSA and CGC pops, a "Fair Value (2026-27)" range below that price, and a reason. Since then the Cardian Pokémon (JP) PSA 10 index, which tracks the 100 most-traded Japanese cards from sold prices in Japan, has fallen 6%. All four cards fell further.

Chart 5All four 'Project Overpriced' cards fell 20% to 42% since March; the index fell 6%

Japanese PSA 10 price change from the price in our 17 March post to 13 October, in S$

−40%−20%0%Pokémon (JP)PSA 10 index−6%Mega Charizard Xex SAR−20%Umbreonex SAR−29%Mega Gengarex SAR−39%Pikachuex SAR−42%−40%−20%0%Pokémon (JP)PSA 10 index−6%Mega Charizard Xex SAR−20%Umbreonex SAR−29%Mega Gengarex SAR−39%Pikachuex SAR−42%

Charizard, the biggest name, fell least. The two Mega Dream ex cards, whose 10s more than doubled, fell most.

Source: Cardian Instagram 'Project Overpriced' (17 Mar 2026) for the March prices; Cardian Pokémon (JP) PSA 10 index and its member prices, sold prices in Japan, converted at the 9 Oct rate

Two of the four are now inside the March range, while Umbreon is 7% above it and Charizard 33% above. The two Mega Dream ex cards, Mega Gengar and Pikachu, more than doubled their tens in seven months, and they fell the most. For the Pikachu the post's reason read: "Pop should break 10k by end-27. Non-promo pika usually dont hold value very well w/ high pop." Its PSA and CGC tens have since gone from 6,407 to 17,039.

Chart 6The two cards whose 10s grew 2.5× or more fell about 40% since March

Cards from our 17 March 'Project Overpriced' post, on 13 October 2026

Card10s in Mar → nowPrice since Marvs March range
Mega Charizard X ex SAR29,777 → n/a*−20%33% above
Umbreon ex SAR70,102 → 75,515−29%7% above
Mega Gengar ex SAR7,907 → 19,693−39%inside
Pikachu ex SAR6,407 → 17,039−42%inside

10s are PSA + CGC. *Our count for the Charizard is mis-recorded, so we've left it out rather than guess. The March ranges were for 2026–27.

Source: Cardian Instagram 'Project Overpriced' (17 Mar 2026); Cardian Pokémon (JP) PSA 10 index member prices; Cardian population data (PSA + CGC), 13 Oct 2026

Charizard went the other way. In March it had by far the biggest pop of the three Mega-era cards, yet it fell the least, which I see as the popularity factor at work. On 1 September we wrote that "The Moonbreon of the Mega era just flashed its first BUY signal", and since then our Japanese PSA 10 index has fallen 12%. Today the card is 20% below its March price.

What to do

Run this before you buy a card to hold

I still look at 5,000 when I price a slab, but now as the point where I first check how fast the pop is growing and whether the set is still being printed. A card can carry a big pop if the right people want it, and I'll keep updating these charts as the population data grows.

Data as of 13 Oct 2026. Charts show the numbers on the day this was written.

Sources

  1. Cardian pop-vs-price data: PSA + CGC 10 counts and PSA 10 sold prices, 2,191 English and 349 Japanese cards worth US$100+ as a PSA 10, 13 Oct 2026 — link
  2. Cardian grade ladder and grading data by era (median PSA 10 ÷ raw, median gem rate), English and Japanese Pokémon, 13 Oct 2026 — link
  3. Cardian Pokémon (JP) PSA 10 and raw indices: the 100 most-traded Japanese cards, from sold prices in Japan, data to 13 Oct 2026 — link
  4. Cardian Instagram, 'Project Overpriced' (17 Mar 2026), 'How to tell if a Pokémon card will become valuable' (22 Mar 2026), 'Price vs Rarity' (Feb 2026) and 'The Moonbreon of the Mega era' (1 Sep 2026): March prices, populations and fair-value ranges, and the lines quoted
  5. Cardian website, 'Pokémon Card Price vs Rarity: Why Rare ≠ Valuable (and the 5,000 PSA 10 Rule)' (25 Feb 2026) and 'How to Tell If a Pokémon Card Will Become Valuable: A 4-Factor Framework' (24 Mar 2026), quoted — link
  6. Guinness World Records, 'Logan Paul's rare Pokémon card becomes most expensive ever sold in record-setting auction' (Pikachu Illustrator PSA 10, US$16,492,000 at Goldin, 16 Feb 2026) — link

More research

All research →