Cardian Research · Japanese cards · Sealed · Valuation · Grading
Forest Pikachu: when the cost to pull is a floor, and when it isn't
On 7 July we wrote that this 1-in-100 Pikachu "might now be trading below what it actually costs to pull one". Two restocks later, with a third due, here's the sum done again with the ¥891 retail deck price, the McDonald's Pikachu as a warning, and when the argument holds at all.
In July we bought our first PSA 10 of Forest Pikachu, the Pikachu ex special art rare (SAR, the full-picture premium version of a card) that only comes in one deck out of a hundred, and paid about S$2,800. Our Instagram post on 7 July explained the sum behind it, where each "box" is one deck: "~S$45 a sealed box X ~100 boxes to hit one = ~S$4,500 to pull it yourself". It went on: "If box prices hold, the single looks undervalued vs. the cost to produce one".
Since then the maker has restocked the product again, with another restock due in Japanese shops on 24 October, and public auction sales show its PSA 10 down 18% between March and August. So this piece checks the sum again. Is the card really below its cost to pull, meaning what it costs to open enough decks to get one? What does the McDonald's Pikachu tell us about cards like this, and when is "below the cost to pull" a good reason to buy anything?
What happened
One deck in a hundred, and every deck can be weighed
Start Deck 100 Battle Collection came out in Japan on 19 December 2025 at ¥891 a deck. Each sealed pack is one ready-to-play 60-card deck, picked at random from 100 numbered decks plus two secret ones: deck 101, which holds three Mega SARs, and a variant of deck 001 with a gold Mega Charizard Y ex. Pikachu ex 764/742, drawn by booota, is only in deck 025, which is why people treat each pack as a lottery ticket.
Decks you'd open, on average, to find each hit (100 numbered decks plus two secret ones)
Every numbered deck has the same odds. The rarity is real; what changes the maths is how many decks get printed.
Source: PokeBeach deck list (16 Dec 2025) and 1,000-deck opening (22 Dec 2025); pokecazilla deck odds (25 Sep 2026)
The odds match what the maker says. Japanese guides report that the numbered decks turn up in equal numbers, and a widely shared opening of 1,000 decks found deck 101 just four times and no gold Charizard at all. Our July post listed "ALL five SAR decks (No.25/27/54/72/82)"; the published deck lists put the Pikachu in 025, Lillie's Clefairy ex in 032 and the three Mega SARs together in 101.
People found the catch within days of launch. PokeBeach warned on 22 December that every deck can be weighed to tell whether it holds a hit, so the sealed decks that reach a casual buyer may already have been checked and the hits taken out. That made unsearched decks scarce and pushed their resale price far above ¥891. Our July sum used about S$45 a deck, against a retail price of about S$7.19.
What happened
The maker kept printing
The odds per deck are only half the story. The other half is how many decks exist. On launch day the official Pokémon Card Game site said it would keep making more Start Deck 100 as sales needed, and it has done exactly that.
| When | What |
|---|---|
| 19 Dec 2025 | Launch at ¥891. The maker says it will keep printing as demand requires |
| Jan–Feb 2026 | Same booota art in Traditional Chinese, English (Ascended Heroes) and Korean |
| May–Jun 2026 | First restock and shop lotteries in Japan |
| Aug 2026 | Second restock |
| 24 Oct 2026 | Third restock due in shops |
Each restock adds about one Forest Pikachu per 100 decks, at the same ¥891 a deck.
Source: Pokémon Card Game official notice (19 Dec 2025); Bulbapedia; pokemon-infomation.com (13 Jun 2026); Famitsu (17 Jun 2026); pokecazilla (25 Sep 2026); nyuka-now (5 Oct 2026)
Japan had restocks in May and June and again in August, and a third is listed for 24 October. The same booota artwork was also printed in Traditional Chinese in January, in the English Ascended Heroes set on 30 January, and in Korean in February. None of those is the Japanese 764/742, but they all compete for the same buyer, the one who simply wants that picture of Pikachu.
The grading numbers show the new supply coming in. Our 7 July post counted "5092 PSA 10 copies graded at PSA (gem rate:88%)", and by early September PSA had graded 6,858. The card comes back a 10 about 85% of the time, so most copies sent in become perfect slabs, and the English version already has more PSA 10s than the Japanese card.
PSA 10 copies graded so far
Forest Pikachu grades 10 85% of the time, and its count rose from 5,092 in our July post to 6,858 by early September.
Source: PSA population report (early September 2026); July count from our July post
That is a lot for a "rare" card. Our 25 February post on price and rarity said "if a card has more than 5,000 copies in PSA 10, it's usually high-risk — or low-upside — as an ‘investment’", and Forest Pikachu passed 5,000 this summer. The gold Charizard Y, with 525, shows what truly scarce looks like in this product.
What's happening now
The card fell behind the market, then fell with it
The price shows the same pressure. Forest Pikachu isn't one of the 100 most-traded cards in our Japanese index, and we don't have a copy listed in the shop right now, so I've used public auction sales instead. At public auction, a PSA 10 copy fell 18% between 23 March and 31 August, while our Japanese PSA 10 index rose 7% over the same dates.
Forest Pikachu against the Cardian Pokémon (JP) index over the same dates
Through the spring and summer the card lagged the market by about 25 points. In the last month it simply fell with everything else.
Source: Public auction sales of a PSA 10 copy, 23 Mar and 31 Aug 2026 (percentage change only); Cardian price data for Japanese cards (30-day raw change); Cardian Pokémon (JP) indices, raw and PSA 10
In the last 30 days the raw (ungraded) card fell 13%, about the same as our raw index. So the card fell behind in spring and summer, when the restocks began, not in the market-wide slide since September.
What's next
The McDonald's Pikachu has 43 times as many PSA 10s
The warning in our 7 July post was the McDonald's Pikachu. The post said it peaked on the same "it's Pikachu, it's rare" logic, and went on: "Then Japan's real supply surfaced. Never recovered. Supply beats hype". In August 2025 McDonald's Japan put Pokémon cards in its Happy Sets, resellers cleared the stores within a day and left piles of uneaten food behind, and the AP reported the cards reselling for up to tens of thousands of yen. McDonald's apologised. The logic at the time was the same as Forest Pikachu's: it's Pikachu, and nobody can get one.
The supply turned out to be enormous. PSA has now graded 293,453 PSA 10s of that card, 43 times as many as Forest Pikachu. It's still one of the 100 most-traded PSA 10s in our Japanese index, so the demand never went away, but its PSA 10 now trades far below the resale prices reported during the August 2025 scramble. Plenty of people want it and it's still cheap, because everyone who wants one can have one.
Forest Pikachu isn't at that point. You need about a hundred decks for each copy rather than one meal, and the McDonald's card has 43 times as many PSA 10s. The lesson that applies here is narrower but still important: popularity doesn't hold up a price when the maker will print as many as people will buy.
What's next
When "below the cost to pull" works, and when it doesn't
Here's the sum done properly. The cost to pull a PSA 10 is the deck price times a hundred, plus about S$31 to grade it through us, divided by the 85% chance it comes back a 10. At the S$45 a deck used in our July sum, that's about S$5,300 for a PSA 10. At the ¥891 retail price, about S$7.19, it's roughly S$880.
Expected cost of one PSA 10 by opening decks (100 decks, grading, 85% gem rate), S$ thousands, by the price you pay per deck
At the ¥891 retail price (about S$7.19) a PSA 10 costs roughly S$878 to pull; at the S$45 a deck in our July sum, S$5,306.
Source: Cardian calculation: ¥891 retail (PokeBeach, 22 Dec 2025) at S$0.00807 per yen; 1 deck in 100; PSA gem rate 85.4% (PSA population report); S$31 grading and shipping through Cardian; S$2,800 is what Cardian paid for a PSA 10 in July
We paid about S$2,800 in July. Opening decks only costs more than buying the slab if you pay more than about S$24 a deck. So for anyone who can buy at retail, the card sells well above its cost to pull, and each restock gives more people that chance. Weighing makes it worse. Sellers who buy decks at retail and weigh them make new copies more cheaply than anyone else, and then they sell the singles.
That points to a general rule. "Below the cost to pull" is a floor only when the product is no longer being made, so the sealed price is set by scarcity and can only climb. While it's still being printed, the real cost is the retail price, and singles slowly move toward it. The argument also works better when sealed product can't be searched, when the PSA 10 count has stopped rising quickly, and when there's one version of the art rather than four.
On 7 July we wrote: "We have a price for every card — and we think this one's right". Since then the maker has restocked again in August, and at retail a PSA 10 costs about S$880 to pull. My own rule from here is to wait for the restocks to stop before paying a high price for another, and I'll redo these numbers when they do.