Cardian Research · Japanese cards · Market · Valuation · Grading
Is Pokémon 151 still a buy? What happened after the March spike
In March, 151 singles jumped as much as 114% in a month. Seven months later, the Japanese market is below its March level and 151 is leading the October bounce. Here's what drove the spike and what decides 151 from here.
In the first weeks of March, the chase cards from Pokémon 151 had their best month since the set came out. For the three cards in our Instagram post, Japanese PSA 10s rose 25% to 63% in a month and English raw copies, meaning ungraded, rose 63% to 114%. On 11 March we wrote: "Given the magnitude of the surge, I DON'T recommend chasing". Under the heading "If i die die want spend $$?", the same post said "BUY JAPANESE if you have to!" and explained why.
Seven months later, this piece looks at what caused the spike, what the market has done since, and what helps or hurts 151 from here. Most charts use the Cardian Pokémon (JP) index, which tracks the 100 most-traded Japanese cards from sold prices in Japan. We also use PSA population data, which counts how many cards PSA has graded at each grade.
What happened
A rotation, a birthday, and a set that took two years to get going
The trigger people pointed to was rotation. Tournaments only allow recent cards, which are marked by a letter printed in the bottom corner. Every 151 card has a G. In January the Pokémon Company confirmed that G cards would leave the Standard format on 10 April 2026, and on 26 March in the online game. A set nobody plays is less likely to be printed again. Our post called rotation "The strongest signal yet that the set will never be reprinted again," though the company has said nothing about reprints.
The second push was the calendar. Pokémon Red and Green came out in Japan on 27 February 1996 with exactly 151 Pokémon, so the 30th anniversary fell right on the set built around them. By April, Bleeding Cool's Value Watch column was calling it "big time growth for 151" and saying it was because packs had become hard to find.
The third thing is easy to forget: 151 wasn't hot for most of its life. Japanese 151 launched on 16 June 2023, and a lot of it was printed. The Pokémon Center took orders for made-to-order boxes that June, retailers ran lottery re-sales in the autumn at ¥5,200 a box, and another Japanese reprint was announced for December 2024.
English 151 arrived on 22 September 2023 with no booster boxes, only special products. It got one more in February 2025, a premium collection with 12 packs. China got its own version, Collect 151, on 17 January 2025, with four Pikachu Art Rares found nowhere else, which we covered in our piece on Chinese exclusives.
Japanese 151's 15 priciest raw cards, launch week = 100, weekly, first two years. Typical = the median Japanese set at the same age
151 did worse than a normal set in its first year, then spent the second year climbing back while most sets kept sliding.
Source: Cardian set curves: each Japanese set's 15 priciest raw cards from sold prices in Japan, weights capped at 20% (cardian.sg/market/method)
That supply shows up in the set's price curve. A year after launch, the 15 priciest Japanese 151 cards were 56% below their launch week, a worse first year than the typical Japanese set. Then they climbed back through the second year. At the two-year mark they were at 91% of the launch price, against 58% for the typical set. So by March 2026, 151 had shown it could hold its value despite a big print run, which is why casual buyers saw it as the "safe" set.
What happened next
Six more weeks of gains, then the whole market turned
From 11 March, the Japanese market kept rising for about six weeks: raw cards rose another 29% to 26 April, and PSA 10s rose 19% to 18 April.
Japanese Pokémon market, rebased so 11 Mar 2026 (our post) = 100, daily. G-mark rotation: 10 Apr
Prices kept rising for about six weeks after 11 March, then gave it all back and more.
Source: Cardian Pokémon (JP) indices: the 100 most-traded Japanese cards, from sold prices in Japan, raw and PSA 10 (cardian.sg/market/method)
Then the whole market turned. Today the raw index is 21% below where it stood on 11 March and the PSA 10 index is 7% below, so someone who bought in March is still at a loss even after October's bounce. That was the market-wide fall, which our piece on the sell-off covers. We don't have a separate 151-only history for the whole year, and our sealed tracker covers only One Piece boxes so far, so I can't say whether 151 cards or boxes did better or worse than the index.
What happened next
English led the market, and the 151 price gap narrowed a little
Across the wider market, English cards did far better: since 11 March our English raw index is up 25% and its PSA 10 index 60%, while Japanese fell. But our English index is mostly vintage, and its PSA 10 basket has no modern cards at all, so it tells us little about 151 itself.
For 151 itself, the closest comparison is the card from the March post. Going by the PSA populations quoted at the time, about 26,600 English 10s and 33,900 Japanese, that was the Charizard ex Special Art Rare (SAR). In March the English PSA 10 sold for 2.64 times the Japanese one, and today it sells for 2.38 times, so the Japanese copy gained about 10% against the English one. This is only rough, because the March figures were single last sales.
Same artwork. Price: English PSA 10 ÷ Japanese PSA 10. Pop: Japanese PSA 10s ÷ English PSA 10s
For the five SARs the pops are within about a third of each other, yet English costs 2.3 to 2.5 times as much. For the two Art Rares, Japan simply has 3 to 5 times more 10s.
Source: PSA population report (Oct 2026); Cardian price data, PSA 10 sold prices in the US for both languages, 12 Oct 2026
The post gave its reason as "Similar population, MASSIVE price gap". Today the Charizard, Blastoise, Venusaur, Zapdos and Alakazam SARs have roughly as many PSA 10s in Japanese as in English, yet the English slab costs 2.3 to 2.5 times as much. The Art Rares are a different story, because Japan has three to five times as many Pikachu and Charmander 10s, so the bigger price gap there is justified, not a bargain.
What's next
What holds 151 back: lots of perfect copies
That leads to the real weakness of Japanese 151, which is supply at the top grade. Across the sets we track, 77% of Japanese cards sent to PSA come back a 10, against 35% of English ones, and 151 is an extreme case.
Cards graded by PSA and how many got a 10, Pokémon 151, millions
About 79% of Japanese 151 cards sent to PSA come back a 10, against 31% of English ones.
Source: PSA population report (Oct 2026), 150 tracked cards per set
Across the set, PSA has graded about a million Japanese 151 cards and given 798,000 of them a 10, against 265,000 tens for English. When 79% of Japanese submissions come back perfect, a 10 isn't scarce, and prices reflect that (our piece on grading covers what that means for submitting).
PSA 10 price ÷ raw price, the 151 cards in our Japanese index, 13 Oct, with each market's median
When 8 in 10 copies grade a 10, the slab adds little on top of the raw card. The Japanese 151 chase cards sit at or below the Japanese norm.
Source: Cardian Pokémon (JP) index members, sold prices in Japan; Cardian PSA 10 premium, median per market (cardian.sg/market/premium)
A Japanese 151 PSA 10 sells for 1.3 to 3.0 times the raw card, at or below the Japanese norm of 2.9 times and far below the 6.0 times that English cards get. For a collector this cuts both ways. A raw Japanese copy gets you most of the card for much less, but the slab is unlikely ever to become rare, because anyone with a clean raw copy can make another.
What's happening now
October: 151 is leading again
The October bounce looks familiar. Since our PSA 10 index bottomed on 1 October, the five 151 PSA 10s in it are up a median 29% against 23% for the rest, and the Charizard ex SAR slab alone is up 45% in under two weeks. Raw 151 is up 3%, with the rest of the raw index flat.
Median price change since 1 Oct, cards in the Japanese index
A small sample (5 PSA 10s and 7 raw cards), but 151 is leading the October bounce, as it led the March run.
Source: Cardian Pokémon (JP) indices: the 100 most-traded Japanese cards, from sold prices in Japan, raw and PSA 10 (cardian.sg/market/method)
It's a small sample, but it matches how the set moved in March. New and returning buyers go for 151 first because everyone knows the Pokémon and the cards are easy to sell. It also carries more weight than any other set in our Japanese raw index, at 9.4%. Being easy to sell is a strength, but it also makes 151 the first set to move when the mood turns, in both directions.
What's next
So, is 151 still a buy?
The long-term case is solid. The original 151 are the Pokémon most collectors grew up with, and to my eye the Art Rares are some of the best illustrations of the Scarlet & Violet era. The set also survived a heavy print run to end its second year near its launch price. Now that it has rotated, I'd expect new supply to come through special products, as English did in 2025, rather than another main print, though that's my reading and not a company statement.
But 151 isn't scarce. There are close to 800,000 Japanese PSA 10s, and Collect 151 shows the company is happy to bring the set back in new forms. So my answer to the title is yes for collecting and no for chasing.
Buy the cards you like, raw and Japanese where the art is the same, a few at a time and not right after a 45% jump in two weeks. For scale, the Japanese Pikachu Art Rare is S$44.80 raw in our shop today. If you want a slab that stays scarce, the English SAR PSA 10 is the better pick, but you pay about 2.4 times the Japanese price for it.
In March I wrote "I DON'T recommend chasing", and with the Charizard slab up 45% in two weeks, I'd write it again today. I think the Japanese copy is the better way to own 151, as a raw card for the art rather than a slab for the scarcity, and I'll update these numbers once the bounce settles.